Who is to blame for the current crisis in general practice? NHS England? The government? Jeremy Hunt? Workforce planners? The bankers because of what happened in 2008? Millennials, because of their demand for instant-everything? Somebody else?
Whose job is it to sort out the crisis that general practice is in? Is it the same people whose fault the crisis is in the first place? Or is it Simon Stevens, NHS England, Jeremy Hunt, the government, or maybe even the BMA and the national general practice organisations?
These will not be unfamiliar questions for GPs. The injustice of the current situation pushes them into almost constant consideration. But focussing on them does not help individual GPs and practices find a way through the challenges they have to contend with on a day to day basis.
I am sure many readers will have at some point come across Stephen Covey’s book, “The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People”, first published in 1989 with over 25 million copies sold. Within the very first habit that Covey identifies of very successful people (“be proactive”), he introduces the Circle of Concern and the Circle of Influence.
The Circle of Concern contains all those things we focus our energy and efforts on over which we have little or no control, such as the weather, Iran’s nuclear programme, or national debt. For GPs it includes working out who to blame for the crisis afflicting the profession, and considering how much of the soon to be announced additional NHS funding will make it to front line general practice.
The Circle of Influence contains all of those things that we can directly control or influence, such as our actions, our behaviours, our family and our colleagues. For GPs this includes their own individual practice.
The habit successful people have, according to Covey, is focussing their energy and effort in the Circle of Influence where they can make a difference, and not wasting it in the Circle of Concern over which they have little or no influence.
I see this difference regularly in GP practices. The factors causing the crisis are outside of the control of practices. The local response to them, however, is within their control. Some GPs and practices focus their energy on the former, and some on the latter.
The barrier that stops many GPs focussing on the Circle of Influence and the changes they can make is this question of who is to blame for the challenges the practice faces, and whose job it is to sort it out. If it is not my fault, and I am essentially a victim of a system failure, why should I be the one who has to sort it out? Letting go of the unfairness of the situation is far easier said than done.
But the practices who are thriving and doing best in the current environment are those focusing their energy within their Circle of Influence; the ones who are looking at how their own behaviours and actions and relationships can influence and change the current situation for the better. They have not waited to react to changes that others will make at a national or policy level, but have taken things into their own hands.
I recently visited Thistlemoor Medical Centre in Peterborough. The majority of their local population do not have English as a first language, and recruiting GPs has been a longstanding problem. But they have focussed on what they can control, and have created a really innovative model so that instead of relying on Language Line they have trained HCAs recruited from the local community to both interpret and take work off the GPs (you can find out more about their model in an upcoming episode of the General Practice Podcast). The practice is thriving and continues to grow at well over 1,000 patients a year.
In Plymouth three practices merged in 2014 to form Beacon Medical Group, and they created a new multidisciplinary team to manage the on-the-day demand. Since then, in the midst of a really challenging local environment, the practice has grown and continued to prosper.
These are just a couple of examples, and there are many across the country. What they have in common is that local GPs focussed on what they could control not what they could not, and took action. They did not waste their energy assigning blame or hoping for national solutions, but instead channelled their efforts within their own Circle of Influence to change the direction in which they were heading.
Thinking about who is to blame for the crisis in general practice is considering the wrong question. It is operating in the wrong circle. The real question to consider is what can I do, what can I influence, to create a vibrant and positive future for my practice, and to focus all my energy and efforts there.
No Comments